
Five Netflix rom-coms to watch if you loved ‘Guarding Stars’
Would you look at that: Christmas has clearly arrived rather early on Netflix this year, with hits like The Gospel of Christmas and The Christmas Switch taking over Netflix charts, and apparently, that wasn’t enough, because now we have the most awaited film of this holiday season: Guarding Stars.
You see, what everyone has decided to do this Christmas is fall desperately in love with precisely the wrong person. Anyway, Guarding Stars, starring Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki, looks to be a delightful festive affair, although Cupid seems to have made a morass of things.
Meester plays Hannah Brooks, a bodyguard who’s been hired to protect Hollywood heartthrob Jack Stapleton. Perfectly ordinary arrangement, you’d think. Except, of course, she somehow ends up at his family’s ranch in Montana over Christmas, pretending to be his girlfriend.
And naturally, things become complicated. There’s the small matter of convincing his family they are madly in love while keeping her actual job under wraps and, inconveniently, trying not to fall for the man she’s supposed to be protecting.
Anyway, you definitely seemed to love that idea; otherwise, why would you be here? And so, we have rounded up five Netflix rom-coms involving fake relationships and secret identities just so you don’t have to watch Guarding Stars on loop fifty more times.
Five Netflix movies to watch if you loved Guarding Stars:
Our Little Secret (Stephen Herek, 2024)
As an adult, you’ve probably had at least one Christmas when you’ve wanted to stay home and see absolutely nobody. And if you need another excuse, Our Little Secret should provide you with all the justification you require, because we cannot think of anything more dreadful than showing up at your partner’s family gathering only to find that your ex is there too, dating your partner’s sibling, of all people.
Yup, that’s the unfortunate situation Avery and Logan find themselves in, and to make matters worse, nobody in the family has any idea that the two were once romantically involved.
Now, the face of rom-coms, aka Lindsay Lohan, is an absolute delight as Avery, while Kristin Chenoweth is brilliant as the meddling family matriarch who makes an already uncomfortable situation even worse. And whereas Guarding Stars has its leading lady pretending to be in a relationship that doesn’t exist, these two poor souls are going to great lengths to conceal one that most certainly did, which is amusing when you consider how much trouble a little honesty might have saved them.
My Secret Santa (Michael Rohl, 2025)
It’s almost impossible to know what it is about Christmas that makes reasonable people abandon all common sense like a film does to the aftermath of a supposed “happy ending”, but My Secret Santa takes things to an extraordinary level, with Alexandra Breckenridge playing Taylor, a single mum who is so desperate to pay for her daughter’s snowboarding camp that she decides the most sensible course of action is to disguise herself as Father Christmas and apply for a job at a luxury ski resort.
And if you thought Hannah’s little fake-girlfriend situation in Guarding Stars was a dreadful predicament, Taylor’s managed to get herself into an even more ridiculous one because, as luck would have it, she now fancies her boss, Matthew, who has no clue that the man dressed as Santa is actually the woman he’s been getting to know.
It’s strange yet funny how she intends to pursue a romance while keeping up the Santa act. Still, people, if ever there was a time for a Christmas miracle, this would certainly be it.
Christmas with You (Gabriela Tagliavini, 2022)
Yet another thing Christmas movies forever try to convince us of is that celebrities are just ordinary people who happen to have unbelievable bank accounts. Well, Christmas with You is certainly no exception, although we must say Freddie Prinze Jr. makes the whole business quite enjoyable. The story follows a pop star who’s desperate for a Christmas hit and eventually finds herself visiting a young fan, only to develop something of a romantic interest in the girl’s father, who happens to be a music teacher.
And much like Guarding Stars, here comes someone who is so used to being the centre of attention that they ultimately find out that their celebrity status doesn’t count for much when they get to celebrate it like ordinary people. In this case, our glamorous pop star begins to realise that spending Christmas with someone she likes might be far more rewarding than another chart-topping single.
Granted, the romance is a bit too sentimental, and we wouldn’t expect the musical numbers to trouble the Grammys anytime soon, but again, you aren’t here for a critically acclaimed hit!
Holidate (John Whitesell, 2020)
Ahh, the perfect holiday classic! Yes, yes, we know that you might’ve already watched it a billion times, but we do wish more Christmas romances had the nerve to be a little unpleasant like Holidate because it is at its best when Emma Roberts and Luke Bracey are being absolute horrors to one another.
Their characters, Sloane and Jackson, agree to be each other’s dates for every holiday occasion, having decided they’ve endured quite enough unsolicited opinions about their romantic prospects from their families. Fair enough, although one does wonder why two people who claim to have no interest in each other spend so much time behaving like a couple in the middle of a dreadful argument.
Now, Guarding Stars has its leading lady putting on a romantic performance for an audience, but these two seem determined to fool themselves, which is arguably more embarrassing. The jokes can be crude, and some are absolute stinkers, but Roberts and Bracey make the bickering worth enduring.
The Royal Treatment (Rick Jacobson, 2022)
Guarding Stars might have a Hollywood heartthrob, but The Royal Treatment raises the romantic complications with an actual prince. You see, nobody is watching The Royal Treatment for an accurate depiction of royal protocol, surely, and the film seems well aware of that.
Putting an outspoken New York hairdresser in a palace full of people who could do with lightening up is half the fun. Isabella is hired to style guests at Prince Thomas’s wedding, only for the couple to develop feelings that complicate his impending arranged marriage.
Laura Marano brings an entertaining impatience to Isabella, while Mena Massoud makes his royal character endearing. The class divide is painted in broad strokes, and the palace romance is pure fairytale nonsense. But Christmas is hardly the season for scrutinising the finer details of royal engagements, is it?